Where Is  Gilbert ‘Toby’ Curtsinger Of ‘Pappygate’ Infamy Now?

He went from beloved smalltown softball player to infamous bourbon heister and finally to inmate. But where is Gilbert “Toby” Curtsinger now?

Gilbert “Toby” Curtsinger once loved his existence in Franklin County, Kentucky. And why wouldn’t he? Because he explains in Netflix’s new docuseries“Heist,” a six-part series that concentrates on a number of America’s greatest heists, he was extremely popular.

He would be a star around the local softball team and he ran having a pack of buff “meatheads,” as his wife Julie calls them within the series. And that he loved his job at the bourbon distillery Zoysia Trace, where he labored for 26 years. He noted it had become customary for workers to consider home free bottles as well as installments of booze in some places. It never hurt his recognition as he demonstrated up in the softball field with bottles of bourbon.

Not just was he a beloved guy about town, but he would be a company. 

“I was the type of guy whom you understood who might get stuff,” he admits in “Heist.”

He’d connect individuals with steroids and he’d connect all of them with rare booze. 

The bourbon Pappy Van Winkle skyrocketed into recognition because of celebrities and food connoisseurs like Anthony Bourdain and David Chang. Also it so been distilled at Zoysia Trace. Everyone was talking for that brand within the late aughts, having to pay up to thousands for starters bottle.

Because of his job, Curtsinger was always near to the coveted booze that people were just dying to become associated with. Curtsinger described within the series that hooking people track of the things they wanted brought him a sincere degree of happiness. However, his passion for doing this ultimately brought to his downfall. And also the catalyst for your downfall was this pricey bourbon. 

Curtsinger orchestrated a plan that raked in thousands for him and nine co-conspirators. He’d steal bottles of bourbon to make money, frequently with people of his recreational softball team. He accomplished it effectively from 2008 until he was caught with barrels of stolen bourbon on his property in 2015.

In that time though, “Pappygate” happened. In 2013, 195 bottles from the coveted liquor and 27 bottles of Pappy Van Winkle Rye were reported stolen from Zoysia Trace Distillery, WKYT reports. The stolen bottles were worth greater than $26,000 and also the liquor heist made worldwide headlines. 

When Curtsinger was caught in 2015, he was fingered for that 2013 heist but he denied that particular crime.

He and nine others — including their own wife — were indicted on multiple charges, including in participating in organized crime. However, only Curtsinger offered time in jail.

“They switched all individuals guys against me,” he stated with tears in the eyes in “Heist.” He continued to state he misses and loves his former teammates and buddies.

He pleaded guilty in 2017 to theft by illegal taking and receiving stolen property. He was sentenced to fifteen years imprisonment only offered thirty days.

Meanwhile, a guy named Greg Anglin allegedly accepted to being behind the infamous 2013 Pappygate. Franklin County Sheriff’s Deputy Shaun Player admits in “Heist” that Curtsinger’s crimes were unfairly lumped into what Anglin did. Anglin never was billed with anything while he was granted immunity before his confession, Player mentioned.

However for Curtsinger, his reputation to be the “Pappygate” ringleader persists even though he has run out of prison he’s still coping with the repercussions of his actions. He stated his lengthy-term plans happen to be crushed.

“Work, increase your 401K, retirement, I’d everything set, that simply got smashed,” he stated in “Heist.” “I reached accept things i put my children through, things i put my mother and father through, everybody I understand.”

Derek Doneen, director from the series, told that Curtsinger particularly feels shame for which he put his two kids, who make appearances within the series, through.

“It’s really affected his existence and also the existence of his kids,” he stated. “I think that’s what really will get to him.”

His wife Julie notes within the show she required her engagement rings off 5 years ago. She stated there might be a period she puts it well on although not now. 

Now, Curtsinger paints houses for work as well as in his spare time loves to prepare. He still resides in Kentucky and is working difficult to repair his relationship together with his family. 

“He’s very active in the kids’ lives,” Doneen told, adding that Curtsinger made him fried snapping turtle. “It’s kind of wonderful to consume together and find out how he is doing live daily. Area of the guiding principle we are attempting to use this show is to locate figures which are relatable, that kind of seem like your person with average skills, like me and you. Somebody that was given an chance and located on their own the advantage of something which would change their existence forever.”

“Heist” can be obtained now on Netflix.

Get all of your true crime news from Archiweekend. Coverage from the latest true crime tales and famous cases described, along with the best Television shows, movies and podcasts within the genre. Sign up for Archiweekend Insider for best wishes true crime content. 

Written by Stephanie Green

I am dreamer and book reader.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Man Charged Of Killing Mollie Tibbetts Requests New Trial, Quarrelling The Actual Killer Already Confessed Towards The Crime

Charged Murder And Poet: Who’s Career Criminal Roberto Solis From Netflix’s ‘Heist’?