‘We Possess A Truckload Of Evidence’: ‘Cold Justice’ Analysis Results In An Arrest In 2007 Murder

In Mauldin, Sc, 44-year-old single mother Debra Chisholm was noted for being fun-loving and getting a large circle of buddies. After her sister died, she helped raise her niece and nephew.

But on December 12, 2007, Chisholm’s nude body was discovered following a fire that started at her home around 10:30 p.m. was released. She’d died from multiple stab wounds and blunt pressure trauma, the coroner reported, based on Who might have murdered her?

Investigators determined the blaze had intentionally been set. Gasoline was utilized being an accelerant, and in addition they found scrape marks along the side of a tree at Chisholm’s home which were thought to happen to be made because the killer hastily drove away. 

For 14 years, no arrests were created within the situation. On the recent episode of “Cold Justice,” airing Saturdays at 8/7c on Archiweekend, veteran prosecutor Kelly Siegler and investigator Steve Spingola visit Mauldin to operate the situation with law enforcement. 

Following a huddle with Mauldin Police Department Det. Shawn Cruz, Sgt. Robert Thacker, and Chief George Miller, three suspects emerge: Chisholm’s nephew and niece, Dwayne and Sakeena Taylor, and her married boyfriend, Dwayne Ishaaq. 

The “Cold Justice” team learns there is bad bloodstream between your victim and her nephew and also to a smaller degree her niece, who believed their aunt withheld their Social Security payments. Chisholm’s daughter, Taineisha Bolden, confirms the household rift to investigators. And due to her nephew’s scrapes using the law along with other issues, Chisholm “kicked him from the house” about two several weeks before her murder, based on part of the Mauldin PD.

Once the “Cold Justice” team interviews Chisholm’s buddies and former boyfriends, consensus about her more and more fractious relationship with Dwayne Taylor emerges. He’d threatened his aunt coupled with plans to find her house shortly before her murder, based on witnesses. 

Investigators turn their focus on Ishaaq, whose alibi about his location on December 12, 2007 are corroborated by his wife in addition to video security cameras. Efforts to talk with Ishaaq don’t succeed. 

When investigators visit Sakeena at her home, she’s reluctant to talk to them. “She found the doorway and made an appearance to become polite,” states Spingola. “However, she certainly gave us the comb off.” “The team wonders if she may have heard greater than she’s prepared to share” When investigators achieve to Sakeena again, she informs these to leave her alone.

Digital forensic expert Eric Devlin’s research into the suspects’ mobile phones are compelling but inconclusive. It reveals “a black hole,” Siegler states, round the murder window — 8:30 p.m. to 11 p.m. that night.

Additionally they talk to the victim’s neighbors, who recall visiting a black truck the night time from the crime. The automobile designed a telltale seem, like “a lawn sprinkler,” the witness states. No three suspects owned that black truck. 

Mauldin PD investigators had noted the victim’s nephew had had vehicle trouble shortly prior to the murder. The “Cold Justice” team tracks lower the garage that serviced his vehicle. The store owner recalls loaning him an automobile — a black truck that designed a distinctive seem. When Dwayne Taylor came back the18 wheeler, it’d damage quietly along with a cap missing from the gas can stowed within the bed.

The dent aligned using the scrape around the tree, as the missing lid attached to the accelerant used. “We possess a truckload of evidence,” states Spingola. 

Investigators’ efforts to interview Dwayne Taylor, who’s in city jail for domestic violence charges, don’t succeed. He refuses to talk to them.

After reviewing the situation, they removes Sakeena and Ishaaq in the suspect list. With solid circumstantial and physical evidence pointing at Chisholm’s nephew, they convey the situation towards the 13th Judicial District Solicitor’s Office. Prosecutors choose to move ahead. 

On September 17, 2021 Dwayne Taylor, 36, was billed with first-degree arson and also the murder of Debra Chisholm.To understand more about this situation, watch “Cold Justice,” airing Saturdays at 8/7c on Archiweekend. You’ll find more episodes here.

Crime Time is the place to go for true crime tales from around the globe, breaking crime news, and knowledge about Archiweekend’s original true crime shows and documentaries. Register for Archiweekend Insider for best wishes true crime content. 

Written by Stephanie Green

I am dreamer and book reader.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

How To Approach A Carjacking: ‘911 Crisis Center’ Dispatchers Handle Back-To-Back Armed Occurrences

Oc Killer Write On Calendar ‘Goodbye’ Around The Date He Stabbed Ex-Boyfriend And The Lover