First Man Charged Of Murder On Genetic Genealogy Evidence Has Verdict Overturned

The very first man found responsible for murder after being associated with a criminal offense via genetic genealogy has already established his two convictions overturned.

William Earl Talbott II was charged of killing 20-year-old Jay Prepare and 18-year-old Tanya Van Cuylenborg later as the Canadian senior high school sweethearts visited San antonio, as formerly reported. Talbott’s 2018 arrest helped set the bar for genetic genealogy, a science which has since boomed and redefined criminal investigations all over the world, based on a report by CBS’ “an hour.”

On Monday, a Washington Condition Appeals Court overturned each of Talbott’s first-degree murder convictions due to juror bias, based on court public records. At the beginning of jury choice for the initial trial, a juror was selected for more questioning when she expressed she may be a fan of evidence potentially presented at trial. The lady, who had been not named, reported past traumatic encounters and her role like a new mother for reasons that they couldn’t be objective.

The defendant’s motion to get rid of the juror in the panel was denied.

However in his latest appeal, Talbott contended that his constitutional to a neutral jury was violated.

A legal court of appeals ruled in the favor.


“After [the juror’s] obvious, repeated expressions of actual bias regarding the precise nature from the allegations in the centre of the trial and evidence which may be introduced, we can’t conclude that juror [number] 40 was sufficiently rehabilitated so that Talbott was provided a good and impartial jury.”

The court’s ruling incorporated transcripts from servings of voir dire, in which the juror referenced becoming an adult inside a violent household.

“I have no idea the way i would feel, being proven proof of something which could mention recollections which i have labored to eliminate,” stated the juror. “I in addition have a daughter, and i believe that may also play a role in the way i might feel. When there was action taken perfectly into a youthful lady, I would take that personally and be unable to be impartial.”

Jurors heard the violent and nasty details behind the murders that Talbott was accused.

Based on court public records, Prepare and Cuylenborg left Victoria, Bc, on November. 18, 1987, to retrieve furnace parts in San antonio for Cook’s father. On November. 24, Cuylenborg’s body is discovered on the steep embankment inside a province of Skagit County. Her pants were removed, and her bra pulled above her breasts. Someone beat her and shot her at the back of the mind at close range.

The very next day, the couple’s van was discovered with bloodstream evidence and Cuylenborg’s missing pants inside.

On November. 26, 1987, Cook’s partly covered body was discovered inside a province in Snohomish County. He sustained blunt pressure trauma towards the mind and it was strangled to dying having a receiver collar and twine. The killer also shoved a pack of any nicotine products lower his throat.

Investigators collected DNA in the van and Cuylenborg’s body.

In 2018, investigators tested the DNA using genetic genealogy, an up-and-coming science which was still relatively recent at that time. The testing, made famous using the ultimate capture of Golden Condition Killer Frederick DeAngelo that very same year, helps police force create suspect profiles through familial DNA links developed using genetic genealogy databases. Talbott was identified just as one source.

Investigators tailed him and picked up an espresso cup he discarded, ultimately tying him towards the murders.

Talbott, a building worker and trucker who resided near where Cook’s body was discovered, was arrested in a job site in May 2018. He was sentenced to existence imprisonment.

Monday’s decision to overturn the murder convictions came like a shock to prosecutors, based on KOMO News.

“We’re disappointed being an office, as you would expect, and I know the household is similarly disappointed,” stated Snohomish County Prosecuting Attorney Adam Cornell. “The proven fact that the trial court didn’t dismiss that juror for cause impacted Mr. Talbott’s to a good trial, and here i am.”

Cornell stated he intends to appeal the condition Top Court before a Jan. 5, 2022 deadline, based on the San antonio-based news outlet. Failing that, his office will endeavour to re-try Talbott.

“This isn’t over yet,” stated Cornell. “We’re likely to still fight for justice of these families.”

Crime Time is the place to go for true crime tales from around the globe, breaking crime news, and knowledge about Archiweekend’s original true crime shows and documentaries. Register for Archiweekend Insider for best wishes true crime content. 

Written by Stephanie Green

I am dreamer and book reader.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Mother Of Three Dead After Thanksgiving Murder-Suicide At California Motel, Government bodies Say

German Man Charged In Dining Table Castrations Situation In Munich Court