Closest Friend Of Murderer Cries As Prosecutor Aims For Dying Penalty In Sentencing Hearing

The sentencing phase for any one-time Florida cheerleader who’s now a charged murderer started on Monday, as prosecutors searched for the dying penalty. 

A jury on Tuesday found Robert Tyrone Hayes, 39, guilty of first-degree murder for killing three women in Volusia County — that is northeast of Orlando — in 2005 and 2006.

The prosecution needs the dying penalty for Hayes, who wiped out the 3 victims in Volusia County when studying at Bethune-Cookman College in Daytona Beach. He was majoring in criminal justice and performing like a cheerleader during the time of the murders.

Prosecutor Andrew Urbanak told the jury on Monday that Hayes’ crimes warranted the dying penalty while he wiped out with coldness and premeditation.

“All these murders were essentially on the script,” he stated. 

He cautioned jurors the defense will declare that Hayes has brain damage, though Urbanak stated the state’s expert found such damage. Also, he cautioned jurors that Hayes’ family members would talk about Hayes’ character.

Hayes’ cousin Denise Johnson then testified that they understood Hayes like a prepare who’d always bring food to her house. 

Jason Caldwell, Hayes’ closest friend since their college days at Bethune-Cookman, testified the defendant helped him get comfortable and chosen campus.

“He required that point that helped me to out,” he stated, adding that Hayes also given him clothing to put on in those days.

“When i state closest friend, I am talking about that’s someone I’m able to rely on anytime or day,” Caldwell stated before choking up. He stated he hasn’t seen the charged murderer contain anger and remembered how Hayes was there for him and the family through the years.

Prosecutors requested Hayes’d character witnesses if they’d ever observed him struggling with mental health issues almost all stated no.

Hayes was arrested inside a 4th murder in 2019 after investigators grabbed a cigarette he flicked right into a beer can and compared it to DNA available at the scene from the murder of Rachel Bey, 32. Bey was discovered sexually mistreated and strangled having a damaged jaw and teeth along the side of the street in Riviera Beach, Florida — about 80 miles north of Miami — in 2016. He still faces a potential trial for that slaying of Bey in Palm Beach County, where he was being employed as a chef during the time of the murders, based on Miami CBS affiliate WFOR.

After that, he was from the 2005 and 2006 murders of Laquetta Gunther, 45, Julie Eco-friendly, 34, and Iwana Patton, 35, through DNA and genetic genealogy. Gunther was discovered between a car parts store along with a mostly empty utility building around Christmas 2005, CBS News reports. Green’s body was discovered under per month afterwards a dust road in a construction site. 30 days later, Patton seemed to be found along a dust road. All were found naked and laying face lower. All were shot with similar gun, based on WFOR.

It had been Hayes’ senior year at school, based on Cincinnati radio station WKRC.

“It would be a single gunshot wound to the rear of the mind in two cases, front from the mind within the cases, inside a remote location where no identification is located, plus they all happened in — as I will repeat throughout this closing argument — strikingly similar fashion,” Prosecutor Andrew Urbanak mentioned during closing arguments a week ago, Law&ampCrime reports. “I undergo you against individuals conditions alone it was a premeditated killing. The place talks to it. How a victims were left talks to it. How a murder was inflicted talks to it.”

Prosecutors stated that Hayes wiped out Gunther, Eco-friendly and Patton once they experienced his vehicle, Orlando CBS affiliate WKMG reported a week ago. Hayes’ defense accepted he had sex together with his victims — therefore comprising the existence of his DNA — but denied killing them, WESH reported.

Gunther, Eco-friendly and Patton all were stated to possess had connections with sex work — though Patton’s niece, who also visited Bethune-Cookman around the same time frame as Hayes, denied her aunt would be a sex worker inside a 2019 interview with WKMG. Prosecutors highlighted throughout the trial that Hayes preyed around the vulnerable, and also the women’s murders struck intense fear within the sex work community at that time. 

Crime News is the place to go for true crime tales from around the globe, breaking crime news, and knowledge about Archiweekend’s original true crime shows and documentaries. Register for Archiweekend Insider for best wishes true crime content. 

Written by Stephanie Green

I am dreamer and book reader.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Man Found Wandering Naked Within The Desert Sentenced For ‘Shocking And Gruesome’ Murders Of 4 Relatives

Jussie Smollett Seeking Retrial — Or Otherwise-Guilty Verdict — Several weeks After Conviction